Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 123 LastLast
Results 16 to 30 of 33

Thread: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

  1. #16

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    Quote Originally Posted by crikey macca View Post
    Just thank your lucky stars you got out there without your prop falling off
    Stick with me CM....I'll make ya a star yet

  2. #17

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    Quote Originally Posted by solemandownunder View Post
    M8, please see above reply & post.......maybe there is a cross-over species is all I am thinking.

    Thanks for taking the time to reply, Ray.
    Ray, get a grip on reality. You have not discovered a new species
    A Proud Member of
    "The Rebel Alliance"

  3. #18

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    Summer Mowong Whiting perhaps

  4. #19

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    Who needs more than 30 livies anyway???

  5. #20

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    Quote Originally Posted by Horse View Post
    Ray, get a grip on reality. You have not discovered a new species
    Bugga


  6. #21

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    This is a Sand Whiting aka Yellowfin Whiting, Summer Whiting. They grow larger than the rest and are often found in shallower water.
    https://www.google.com.au/search?q=y...&tbm=isch&um=1

    The Diver Whiting, aka Winter Whiting only grows to not much more than a handspan and has dark blotches the length of its body.
    Have a good look between this picture and the collection of pictures above in the google search link.
    http://www.google.com.au/imgres?imgu...9QEwAg&dur=232

    Golden-lined whiting look more like a Sand whiting except for size and they have a more rainbow-esque sheen on their flanks.

  7. #22

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    Why would you even want to keep 80 whiting in one outing on your own ???

  8. #23

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    [QUOTE=solemandownunder;1501276]VERY good point Rob...and I have no problems with that..

    At the end of the day, despite the idiots that try to crucify rather than help, I still believe my question is valid.

    Bit rich coming from you after your recent performance on another thread when someone forgot oil.......

    Just saying..........

  9. #24

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    If you cant be 100% sure what you are catching dont keep them.

  10. #25

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    Quote Originally Posted by fishfeeder View Post
    Why would you even want to keep 80 whiting in one outing on your own ???
    To feed me 26 granchillun and me brothers cousins niece AND HER family of 13 under nourished kids...

    Fair point but......you asked, so I will explain....

    As WELL as the many fine people that Kerri & I work with including a lot of people who dont have the physical abilities or funds anymore to actually enjoy some healthy, freshly caught fish....we also give a bit to our local BCF lady who has just had a minor stroke/heart attack ( fresh fish is good for this ), the local DHL guy that delivers our stock, the Aus Post guy who delivers our miscellanious orders from interstate, a friend who lives west of Brissy and doesnt get to fish in salt water because of his job commitments - but LOVES fresh seafood for him & his family etc, etc....

    We give away a lot of what we catch, BECAUSE we CAN...and I guess that means that while we able to help others to lifes' little pleasures, then THEY get that small extra enjoyment that they would otherwise not have, given their personal circumstances.

    Hell.....we even still have 1 whole snapper left atm, kindly donated to us at one point by another fisho here.

    So, WE dont want for much, but the others want even less....a tasty morsel here & there can brighten someones day sometimes....

    Ray & Kerri.

  11. #26

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    [QUOTE=Still_Dreamin;1501490]
    Quote Originally Posted by solemandownunder View Post
    VERY good point Rob...and I have no problems with that..

    At the end of the day, despite the idiots that try to crucify rather than help, I still believe my question is valid.

    Bit rich coming from you after your recent performance on another thread when someone forgot oil.......

    Just saying..........
    jus MAYBE I learnt something from that SD....ever think of that

  12. #27

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    Quote Originally Posted by mattooty View Post
    This is a Sand Whiting aka Yellowfin Whiting, Summer Whiting. They grow larger than the rest and are often found in shallower water.
    https://www.google.com.au/search?q=y...&tbm=isch&um=1

    The Diver Whiting, aka Winter Whiting only grows to not much more than a handspan and has dark blotches the length of its body.
    Have a good look between this picture and the collection of pictures above in the google search link.
    http://www.google.com.au/imgres?imgu...9QEwAg&dur=232

    Golden-lined whiting look more like a Sand whiting except for size and they have a more rainbow-esque sheen on their flanks.
    THANKS for that mattooty.....it would seem from the links you have posted, that no matter WHAT the dorsal......BLOTCHES & Black spot pecs are the definitive answer to identify WINTER/Diver whiting.

    and THAT was all I was wanting to know

    CHEERS, Ray.

  13. #28

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    It's the small wins in life....

  14. #29

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    Its good that you help out others in need..

    But maybe you should spend your time looking for Mackeral, AJs, YTK, Taylor.. you will be able to feed a lot more they what you get from whiting..

    I also give away a lot of fish I catch, But I don't feel the need to keep a bag of every species I catch... just because by law I can.

  15. #30

    Re: DEFINATIVE WINTER/SUMMER Whiting identification....

    Quote Originally Posted by fishfeeder View Post
    Its good that you help out others in need..

    But maybe you should spend your time looking for Mackeral, AJs, YTK, Taylor.. you will be able to feed a lot more they what you get from whiting..

    I also give away a lot of fish I catch, But I don't feel the need to keep a bag of every species I catch... just because by law I can.
    Fair enough....but I DO...horses fer courses I guess.

    The whole aim of this thread was to do what is correct by ALL fisherpeople & lawmakers alike WITHOUT breaking the rules...so to speak.

    I am happy to catch bag limit after bag limit, IF those fish can be utilised and consumed by those around me.

    For ur info FF...I am now turning my attentions to duskys & cobia.....MORE flesh to go around, so to speak.

    Thanks for your help in this thread mate, most appreciated.

    Cheers, Ray.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •