This is an interesting thread & I can relate it back to what my mate is going through.
When we started fishing for impoundment barra a few years back ....... Old mate took a minimalistic approach ( cheap baitcast rod , old ABU / Shimano baitcast reel & armed himself with stump jumper & smilin jack lures) - Never caught a scale in his first couple of trips - Lack of experience more than anything!
Anyhow ..... 12 months ago he landed his first few barra - only small but his first regardless - no changes to his tackle
Back in March he lands his first legal 70 cm fish (in the timber) & he starts to appreciate the power of these little street fighters ! Later in the trip he lands more & bigger barra ....... The cheap rod starts to break up & one of his reels seizes ...... Fish are lost through gear failure or just not having the guts to turn a rampaging mumma ....... I had to lend him one of my outfits to complete the trip
On the most recent trip ..... he has upgraded a rod & now is asking me about another rod & reel ..... after landing & loosing some serious fish - The penny has dropped
So where is this leading to ..... I hear you ask
Like old mate ......... he is now spending more $$ to come up with tackle that even he feels is more appropriate ....... & he hates parting with cash . Clearly he would have been better off spending a bit more to start with .....
Sure you can catch barra on a range of gear ..... even handlines! But if you really want to pursue these magnificent impoundment barra on a regular basis ...... Buy gear that will handle the fish ( over many trips) + enhance the whole experience ..........
Chris
PS .... My choice for a quality budget outfit would be something like Shimano T Curve , Nitro or Pflueger Medalist rods (spin or baitcast) & Reels to look at Daiwa Advantage hsta , Hard rock fish, ABU Revo SX / STX/ Inshore ....... or Spin reels Daiwa Tierra , Shimano Stradic ........... but you would still be spending $400-$500 for a complete outfit