Would you still fish if all fish caught died?

[Great White]

I went yes but not as much. But this poll is a bit out there why not just say would you drink milk if every cow died after it was milked then again a steak and a drink in one meal.

Just my thoughts, but I thought polls were about possible things !!!!

[1lastcast]

I vote no because i dont eat much fish and i only do it for fun i generaly c & r i guess i would have to find a new hobby wich would really suck but i could live with it.
I assume your not asking spear fisherman this question ? lol .

[nigelr]

Yes, I fish for food.
Not saying I don't love fishing, I do, almost to the point of obsession.
But I can't get with it being a sport, personally.
If I can't eat it, I have no desire to disturb it!
Cheers.

[dfox]

Yes, but i'd probably have to go spear fishing a bit more.

[childers]

wonder wat bob thinks of this question !

[NAGG]

:cry: Yes ... I'd still go fishing ... However I'd probably change how I fished & what for .... Nagg

[minno]

Its a bullshit question.



Minno

[minno]

I smell a greenie. I know what your asking, but I think your all on your own.

I will say again! Its a bullshit question. Most of us hunt fish for eating or sport, well from my side of things, I will do my best to let it go, and if iam not going to eat it, well its goes free. and thats a fact. Fishing is what we do, and for most of us, its our hobby. Its still a bullshit question.



Minno

[aussiebasser]

I don't think Sean's a greenie, 'cause if he was he would have used their question which was:

If fish quacked like a duck, barked like a dog, meowed like a cat or cried like a baby, would you still fish?

[Luc]

Have to agree with Minno's comments.

It may be a hypothetical, but those looking for ammo would not think twice about bending the truth.

Luc

[death_ship]

nothing escapes the DEATHSHIP...woohahahahahahahaha woohahahahahaha

[Lovey80]

Sorry mate but I have to agree with minno, rubbish question mate. If I was going to post such a hypothetical it would be along the lines of "If Jennifer Hawkins rang you for a date and you had a missus what would you do"

A. Say yes and go on the date

B. Not go on the date

C. Go on the date but tell your missus

They are both as rubbish as each other but i would prefere thinking about this one a whole lot more..........


I voted yes but a lot less as I would be forced to take everything that wasnt vermin.

Cheers Chris

[Tailortaker]

Well considering Sean voted yes himself I dont think he's a greeny
________
ITUNES GIFT CARDS

[Foxy4]

I don't know if I would because I don't catch that much now anyway.

But I would have to consider the future fish stocks if I was catching heaps each time i did go out.

[seabug]

I voted YES.
But it would not make much difference.
I have not been fishing since March.

Bit like that old favorite.
"When did you stop beating your wife"

Regards
seabug